Scholars & Rogues turns five: thanks for joining us

On April 16, 2007, Scholars & Rogues went live, featuring a post by Gavin Chait (Unlearning helplessness: how donors reinforce poverty and dependency) and one by me on Joe Wilson’s speech at the Conference on World Affairs (where he said that Fred Thompson belonged to the “treason faction of the Republican Party”).

Some highlights:

And on and on. The traffic numbers are no big deal, I suppose – lots of blogs cover that much ground by lunch every day. But we’re not lots of blogs. For one thing, we’re a relentlessly all-volunteer force, with an advertising structure that, in a good month, barely covers our hosting bills. Also, our mission emphasizes depth of analysis in ways that mean by the time we wade in a story may not be hot anymore. We favor quality over quantity and are just fine with the fact that the S&R brand isn’t, and never will be, much for mass market appeal.

We set out to be a political blog with a strong culturalist base, but in the aftermath of the elections we shifted gears a bit, and have since become…well, the semi-official line I tend to use these days (which you’ll see at our Facebook page) is “an online journal of progressive culture.” We still write about politics, but also music, and sports, and poetry, and arts and the environment and popular culture and media and journalism and international affairs and nuclear disarmament. You’ll find photography and videos and political cartoons. We sometimes write straight-up personal narrative and we take the occasional shot at humor. We tend to believe that most everything is ultimately political, and while we passionately believe in fighting for a better world, we understand the difference between battles, which can be over quickly, and wars, which can last generations.

Most of the core group of founders are still here – myself, Dr. Denny, Brian Angliss, Mike Sheehan, Gavin Chait and Jim Booth were in the building on day one. Some have moved on and we have added a variety of wonderful fellow travelers along the way – Russ Wellen, Lex, Wufnik, Otherwise, Wendy Redal, Cat White, Lisa Wright, Chris Mackowski, Terry Hargrove and the n00b, Frank Balsinger, are all members of the sacred initiates of the 32nd order insider cabal of dues-paying members, and we’re also fortunate to have a talented crowd of regular contributors pitching in, as well.

I don’t honestly know what everybody’s expectations were five years ago. Did any of us think we’d last five years? Did we think we’d be rich and famous by now? I have no idea. Mainly I was trying to figure out what to write next and once I did, how we might go about attracting an audience. And not just any audience. We didn’t want millions of readers, we wanted the smartest readers, thoughtful, intelligent folks who would value unconventional ways of looking at the issues of the day and who could populate the comment threads with equally insightful takes of their own, responses that would teach us all and enrich the life of the community.

Obviously that’s not how it always goes down, but I think I’m safe in saying that my fellow scrogues and I are awfully proud of what we’ve accomplished. We thank you for reading and sharing your time and energy with us, and with luck April 16, 2017 will find me back here reporting on even greater successes.

Maybe the world will even be more of that “better place” we all dream of.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s