Jurgen Klinsmann vs. Don Garber at Hell in a Cell: it’s just not that complicated, folks

A few days ago there was another dust-up between US Men’s National Team manager Jurgen Klinsmann and MLS Commissioner Don Garber. In the aftermath we’ve heard analysis upon analysis, take after take, all trying to sort things like why can’t we all get along and why does Jurgy hate America?

I get that controversy is good for certain corners of our society – say, those who make money off of ratings – but I really don’t get why this is so complicated for people. In truth, Klinsmann’s position is straightforward and logical, totally in line with a fact that we all know about athletics: To be the best, you have to compete against the best.

He doesn’t advocate that every player go to Europe. He’s clear on this – you need to be playing at the highest level you can get on the pitch. Playing in MLS is better than riding pine in England, but if you can play in England, that’s where you should be. You should not be playing in MLS if you could be playing in Spain, Italy, Germany, France, and maybe a few more leagues.

Klinsmann can’t be happy about Jozy Altidore’s situation, for instance. Jozy plays for Sunderland in the Premier League, the world’s best. But he spends most of his time on the bench and rarely scores when he gets off it – in brief, he just isn’t good enough for the Prem. Not yet, anyway. If he leaves England for a lesser league where he’s playing regularly, that will make Jurgen happy.

However, other US players – Clint Dempsey and Michael Bradley come to mind – most certainly are good enough to be playing in top European leagues (although, in Dempsey’s defense, he did try his damnedest, and his failure to stick perhaps lies more with the personnel folks in those leagues – and their preconceived skepticism of American talent – than it does him).

It’s also easy enough to predict that while Klinsmann seems to have issues with MLS at the moment, those issues are going to dwindle with time. The why is simple – the league is getting better, and as it does there are fewer places abroad where American players would be better off.

As for Garber, there’s nothing especially complex about his position, either. His job is to grow MLS and it helps the league’s profile when it can attract top players. If a guy who could be starting in La Liga chooses MLS, that’s validation. It helps the league’s credibility with other players, with fans, and by the way, with advertisers. Again, really logical, really straightforward.

Problem is, right now those two goals – what’s best for the #USMNT and what’s best for MLS – don’t sync up. But give it a few years.

In sum, there’s a lot of analysis over this whole Jurgy vs Garber thing, and ultimately it’s a lot simpler than some people make it.

So simmer down. If you enjoy watching hair fly, go for it. Just don’t get caught up in the idea that it needs a lot of deep analysis.

One comment

  • JK has been consistent in his thoughts with respect to MLS and the USMNT and where he feels players should be playing. That being said, I do wonder about guys like Kyle Beckerman and what he thinks about all of this. At the end of the day, Beckerman has played his entire career in MLS and has thrived in this league. And he was good enough to start 3 of 4 World Cup matches (and it could be argued he should have started in the Round of 16)

    Not sure Jozy was ever going to be fit for Sunderland and I agree that JK would be happy for him to leave if he can get regular minutes even if it is in a lower league (Championship) or perhaps a lower level PL team (like my Burnley club)

    Side note: With Dempsey, he was a Fulham legend but wanted Champions League and tried to force a move to Anfield, but ultimately went to Spurs. But I never thought him a fit at WHL or with AVB and we know what happened to him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s