Online dating tips and etiquette: is it rude not to reply?

In the online world, bad behavior can be the best behavior. How is this possible?

Online DatingIn “real life,” when someone approaches and asks you out, you’re obliged by social custom to reply. You may not be interested, but you can’t just pretend that the person isn’t standing there talking to you. That would be unspeakably rude. So we have developed all manner of ways of saying no thanks, in what is hopefully the kindest way possible. None of us likes to be rejected, and if we have any empathy about us at all we’re uncomfortable inflicting pain and/or embarrassment on someone – especially since that person’s only crime is thinking we’re kinda neat.

That isn’t how it works at online dating sites. 

When I first signed up for back in 2010 I didn’t know the rules. I remember feeling obliged, when I got a message from a woman who didn’t interest me, to try and craft a nice reply that didn’t make her feel bad about herself. I also remember sending notes to women I found interesting and getting absolutely no reply at all. Ignored. Stoned. As though I never existed. *tap tap tap* Hello? Testing? Is this thing on?

I soon learned that these are the rules. This is how online dating works. If you get approached by someone you don’t find attractive, for whatever reason, you simply hit delete and move on. Whatever you do, don’t make eye contact. I began adapting to these odd new cultural mores, for a couple of reasons. One, when in Rome, and two, frankly it’s a lot easier than responding and rejecting, something I have always been very bad at and extremely uneasy doing. These women find something potentially valuable about me, and many of them clearly work as hard on their approach messages as I do on mine, trying to appeal to something in my profile that struck them, working to connect the dots and sell me on the idea that they’re really worth my while. How can I be mean to someone who thinks I deserve that kind of effort?

And a couple times, women I have written to actually have replied with nice no thank you messages. When that has happened I have been stunned. And – here’s the odd part – a little uncomfortable. It turns out that I much prefer being ignored to being acknowledged in cases of rejection. If there’s no contact, it’s harder to take it personally. I may not even notice that whomever she was didn’t reply. Busy week, other things to focus on – sometimes I forget I sent a note at all.

But when she writes back, when she makes eye contact, then the rejection becomes personal and I have to think about it. She has taken the time and is making the effort to look me in the eye and make sure I understand that she isn’t interested and to explain why. Stand there and pay attention while I reject you.

In nearly every way I can think of, this is upside-down, ass-backwards and inside-out from how I was brought up. Ignoring someone – someone who is paying you a huge compliment, in fact – is just flat-out rude. My grandmother would be appalled at my lack of manners, at the abject absence of basic compassion. You don’t just ignore people. What the hell – was I raised in a barn, she’d ask?

And yet, here I am, convinced beyond just about any doubt that what we’d call rudeness in our face to face dealings is a far kinder way of behaving in the online world. It’s cleaner, it’s less awkward, and as counter-intuitive as it may seem, ignoring people spares their feelings. It’s the ones who employ actual manners, as we learned them growing up, who make us feel the worst about ourselves.

I see it, I recognize the truth in it, and the part of me who was raised to be a courteous Southern boy who respected the feelings of others is never going to be quite okay with the idea that “rudeness” is the nicest thing I can do for another person.

More to the point, what are the implications for society as more and more of us are socialized according to the rules of online etiquette? What happens as the functional rudeness of Internet culture invades our face to face lives?

Fascinating idea to ponder, and not entirely pleasant….


  • You raise a good point that is much more universal than dating sites.

    One rule that I frequently see in cybersafety curricula is “The rules that apply face-to-face also apply in the online world (be polite, be kind, tell the truth, etc.). But we know this is NOT the case.

    Even though I occasionally get called “sir” to my face (yes, it happened again recently in a restaurant–why is it always a restaurant?), I don’t try in any way to pass myself off as male or a different age or someone I am not. But we know people do that frequently online.

    What about job applicants? The same thing seems to be happening. I try my best to craft kind but direct rejection notes to unsuitable applicants for a reasonable period of time. But then I get a random resume 2 months after the post is filled and that sense of duty evaporates.

    And LinkedIn. This week I had a true OMG moment when I opened my email and found a request to connect from a former “colleague” with anger-management issues who took a verbal 2×4 to the backs of my knees at a final project planning meeting. To this day I get occasional “spider sense tingling” feelings that make me wonder if he’s in the vicinity. Connect with him? Oh no. No way. But is it truly wise to say no? If I saw him in a store I would duck rapidly down the nearest aisle and get out. No kidding. Why should i behave differently online.

  • Simple question.
    We become RUDER (excuse my franglish).
    We become less courteous.

  • kiraelisesteven

    The way I see it, if I’m not interested in a person, I’d just ignore them and I don’t see a problem with that. It’s like subtly saying “I’m sparing you the embarrassment and giving you the subconcious reassurement that maybe i just didn’t see your message??” Either way, ever since I started Mesh I haven’t had to deal with those awk situations- they do a really good job making sure the only people that message you are pretty much what you’re lookin for. So that’s nice!

  • Pingback: Meet the men of Really, guys, are you serious? | Scholars and Rogues | Progressive Culture

  • I think its rude. Especially if someone takes the time to write a message. They are clearly interested in you. The least you can do is say thank you but no thank you. Its a coward move….be a man, or woman. Reply. If you were all that, you wouldn’t be on the site. Plus its good karma.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s